Marketing in the rearview mirror

Are old-school marketing tactics still effective? How do leaflets, billboards and postal mail stack up against online marketing?

In the wake of the recent AWS outage that caused chaos across the internet and paralysed the sales and marketing activities of many thousands of businesses, we thought back to the days when digital marketing did not exist. It got us wondering: How does old school marketing compare to the shiny stuff we see online?

---

For the past two decades, marketing conversations have been dominated by digital: SEO, paid social, programmatic, automation, analytics. But while everyone was busy chasing the next algorithm update, something interesting happened; traditional marketing never went away.

In fact, in many sectors across the UK, it’s quietly proving its continued worth.

Door drop leaflets, postal direct mail, in-store events, billboards and consumer competitions might sound like relics from another era, yet they remain powerful when used strategically and in conjunction with online activity. The question is no longer whether offline marketing still works, but how and when it delivers the most value.

Door Drops: Tangibility in a digital world

Leaflets pushed through the letterbox may seem archaic, but they’re one of the few channels that still guarantee a moment of physical engagement. According to JICMAIL, over 90% of UK households engage with door drop mail in some way, and many items are kept for days or even weeks. (Compare that to the lifespan of a post on social media). For local businesses, retailers, and community campaigns, the ability to reach every home in a postcode remains unmatched.

The limitation, of course, is measurement. While online ads deliver real-time data, leaflets rely on indirect tracking - promo codes, QR links, or redemption data. Yet when integrated with digital retargeting or localised social ads, door drops can significantly lift awareness and drive online conversions.

In-store and experiential marketing: Connection that converts

Post-pandemic, in-store events and brand experiences have made a comeback. Product tastings, live demos and pop-up activations offer what no digital ad can: Human connection. When consumers physically experience a brand, recall and purchase intent increase dramatically.

The best campaigns now merge the physical with the digital livestreaming events, encouraging social sharing, or retargeting attendees online afterwards. These hybrid approaches turn a one-day local event into a week-long digital story.

Postal direct mail: Personalisation that cuts through

Postal direct mail -personalised, addressed and often premium in feel- has enjoyed something of a renaissance. While email inboxes are overflowing and largely ignored, the average UK household receives only a handful of addressed letters per day. For sectors like financial services, utilities, education and fundraising, a well-designed piece of mail can deliver both trust and response.

Yes, the costs are higher than digital, but so is the potential impact. Modern campaigns increasingly use data-driven personalisation and trackable URLs to blend direct mail’s credibility with digital measurability.

Billboards and Out-of-Home: The brand builders

From roadside posters to London Underground takeovers, out-of-home (OOH) advertising remains one of the most powerful brand visibility tools. (It’s very difficult to scroll past a 48-sheet billboard). Digital OOH has added flexibility, allowing for time-of-day targeting, dynamic messaging and even weather-based creative changes.

While it lacks the precision of digital targeting, OOH reinforces credibility and keeps brands top of mind. For awareness and trust-building, it’s hard to beat.

Consumer competitions: The data magnet

Prize draws and competitions have long been a marketing staple, and with good reason. They’re engaging, low-friction and effective for collecting consumer data. The modern twist lies in blending offline and online mechanics: QR codes on packaging, entry via social media, or hybrid incentives linking a physical purchase with a digital follow-up.

As with any promotional activity, compliance with the CAP code is crucial, but when executed properly, competitions can drive both engagement and loyalty.

Offline vs Online: The smart play is integration

The truth is, it’s not a battle between offline and online it’s about orchestration. Offline marketing builds attention, emotion and trust; online channels deliver targeting, analytics and conversion. The most effective campaigns combine the two: A leaflet that drives to a personalised landing page, an in-store event amplified through Instagram, a billboard that triggers mobile retargeting.

For UK marketers under pressure to demonstrate ROI, the smartest strategy is balance. Use digital tools to plan, track and optimise, but don’t overlook the power of tangible experiences that stick in people’s minds and often on their fridges.

Final word

Old-school marketing isn’t dead; it’s just evolved. In a world where digital noise grows louder by the day, physical presence has renewed value. Brands that blend traditional tactics with digital intelligence aren’t nostalgic, they’re strategic. The most modern marketers know that sometimes, the best way to cut through is to go back to the basics.

---

Contact us to learn more about this topic.